Death and Taxes

Governor Wolf earlier this month presented his budget for fiscal year 2015-2016. It was actually one of the more interesting budgets of the past 30 years. Not because it advocated for tax increases and acknowledged a state revenue deficit of over 2.5 billion dollars.

No, this was not just a budget address but almost a complete overhaul of both state government and the tax code. It was a political manifesto as it was a budget.

For decades there have been complaints about the property tax and its inequities. There have been countless solutions, from money from legalized gambling to Allegheny County’s RAD tax—none have stopped the inevitable rise in millage rates. Governor Wolf’s solution is a rate increase and broadening of the base of the state sales tax, with the majority of the additional dollars collected going to local school districts with a mandate to reduce property taxes.

The corporate community has long complained about the high taxes on business in Pennsylvania making us non-competitive with other states in attracting or maintaining businesses. Governor Wolf would complete the long hoped for demise of the Capital Stock and Franchise Tax and also cut the Corporate Net Income rate in half in just two years. He would fund these cuts with the demise of the Delaware Loop hole.

Governor Wolf would use an excise tax on natural gas extraction to increase funding for education and raise the Personal Income Tax to fill the deficit. Plus there would be a tax on cigars and smokeless tobacco to round out the tax smorgasbord.

Reaction from the Republican controlled General Assembly was of course, predictable.

Now whether we will see any or all of these proposed taxes come the end of June when the Pennsylvania Constitution mandates a budget be in place remains to be seen.

There is a deserved skepticism on state mandated property tax reductions, local municipalities, counties and school districts are ultimately responsible for the levying and spending of property taxes. The business tax cuts and closing of loopholes currently has the business community divided between the larger corporations and their S-Corp brethren.

Republican options include selling off the liquor stores and using the money to bridge the revenue gap; fixing the state employee’s pension fund deficits to reduce the cost of the Commonwealth’s contributions into that fund. Or just cutting the state budget even further than the recently unelected Governor Corbett was not willing to do.

Just recently the Independent Fiscal Office proclaimed that our revenue deficit was only 1.8 billion. Regardless, Pennsylvania is not the Federal Government, our beloved Commonwealth is required by law to have a balanced budget.

So whether Governor is successful in the broad sweeping changes his budget calls for or whether the General Assembly is successful in stopping him one thing is ultimately clear.

Taxes will go up. Don’t know which ones or how much. Taxes will go up.

by Nello Giorgetti

 *     *     *     *     *

If you have questions please contact Michelle Vezzani at or the public affairs professional with whom you work.

Highlights of Governor Wolf’s Proposed 2015-2016 Budget

Budget Numbers

  • 2015-2016 budget proposal: $29.884 billion.
  • Most of the tax revenue to come from the Personal Income Tax (40.8%) and the Sales and Use Tax (31.1%).
  • The largest proposed expenditures would be for Human Services ($11.9 billion), Education ($10.1 billion), Corrections ($2.3 billion), and Treasury ($1.2 billion).
  • Federal funds that contribute to the total operating budget of the state would be $27.9 billion.

The following have been proposed as part of Governor Wolf’s 2015-2016 budget plan.

Government Savings and Efficiency

  • Establishes GO TIME (Governor’s Office of Transformation, Innovation, Management, and Efficiency)–an initiative designed to save taxpayers more than $150 million in the next year.
  • Merges the Department of Corrections with the Board of Probation and Parole to eliminate duplicative administrative oversight and provide better outcomes after offenders return to the community.
  • Re-integrates Medicaid into a single delivery system with a goal of realizing $500 million in additional state savings next year.
  • Allows Pennsylvania to enter into Pay for Success projects (also known as Social Impact Bonds) in five areas: 1) early childhood care and education; 2) education, workforce preparedness, and employment; 3) public safety; 4) health and human services; and 5) long-term living and home-and community-based services.

Liquor Store Modernization

  • Modernizes the liquor delivery system to make it easier and more convenient for customers by including Sunday hours, identifying the most convenient locations for customers, and establishing competitive pricing.

Pension Reform

  • Provides for pension investment reforms: reducing management fees and over reliance on high-risk investment strategies.
  • Eliminates “double dip” payments to charter schools in the Public School Code.
  • Guarantees that all actuarially required employer (meaning the government) pension obligations are paid in full.
  • Builds on the pension changes of 2010 (Act 120 of 2010).
  • Establishes a restricted account to ensure that all future employer obligations are paid in full.
  • Refinances a portion of the unfunded liability of the Pennsylvania State Employees’ Retirement System (PSERS) through the issuance of a $3 billion bond (which would be paid for by increased profits from the state liquor store system beginning in FY 2017-2018).
  • Realizes new revenues through the modernization of the current state-run wine and spirits system that would be allocated to school districts to reduce their pension debt.

Tax Changes

  • Provides for the complete elimination of the Capital Stock and Franchise Tax, effective January 1, 2016.
  • Provides for a reduction of the Corporate Net Income Tax from 9.99% to 5.99% in FY 2015-2016; within two years, the rate would drop to 4.99%.
  • Requires combined reporting for corporate taxpayers; companies would file a single return for all subsidiaries at the state level.
  • Decreases the cap on net operating losses from $5 million or 30% of income to $3 million or 12.5% of income.
  • Provides for $3.8 billion of property tax relief effective in the 2016-2017 school year– paid for by an increase in the Personal Income Tax to 3.7%, an increase in the Sales and Use Tax by 0.6 percentage points (to 6.6% statewide), and the elimination of certain exemptions under the Sales and Use Tax (commonly referred to as broadening the base of this tax); this property tax relief incorporates $600 million in revenue from gaming that is already dedicated to property tax reduction.
  • Provides for a severance tax on natural gas extraction to help finance new debt for publicly financed economic development initiatives and for the Pennsylvania Education Reinvestment Act, which would be established to finance the education spending provided for in the governor’s budget plan.
  • Institutes a 1.25% Bank Shares Tax, retroactive to FY 2013-2014.
  • Increases the Cigarette Tax by $1.00 per pack effective October 1, 2015.
  • Imposes a tax on all other tobacco products at 40% of the wholesale value of these products (effective October 1, 2015).

Public Financing for Economic Development Programs and Projects (includes transportation and water and sewer infrastructure)

  • Provides $5 million for a new initiative that combines the Industrial Resource Centers with technological advances of higher education.
  • Provides a $5 million tax credit to manufacturing companies (this tax credit would be funded through the elimination of “under-performing” tax credits).
  • Provides $100 million to the Pennsylvania Industrial Development Authority.
  • Provides $250 million to Business in Our Sites for site development, business expansions, and business relocations.
  • Provides a $1 million increase for World Trade PA.
  • Provides a $2 million increase for Marketing to Attract Tourists.
  • Includes a $1 million increase in Marketing to Attract Business.
  • Includes a $25 million increase for PA First—to facilitate job creation through Opportunity Grants, Infrastructure Development, and Customized Job Training programs.
  • Provides a $15 million increase in Keystone Communities for Main Street, Elm Street, and Core Communities Development projects.
  • Provides an additional $11 million for the Infrastructure and Facilities Improvement program.
  • Includes $775,000 to preserve Pennsylvania’s military communities (Base Realignment and Closure).
  • Provides a $4 million increase to Public Television Technology.
  • Includes $15 million for a Mixed Use Development Program through the Pennsylvania Housing Finance Agency.
  • Supplements revenue generated by Act 89 of 2013 (transportation funding) with $145 million in bonds scheduled to be issued in FY 2014-2015 under Act 89 of 2013.
  • Leverages more than $500 million through the issuance of PennVEST revenue bonds to address deteriorating municipal water and sewer systems.

Public Financing for Energy Projects

  • $30 million for Combined Heat and Power (Cogeneration).
  • $20 million for Wind Power.
  • $20 million for Green Agriculture.
  • $30 million for the Pennsylvania Energy Development Authority.
  • $25 million for “Last Mile” Natural Gas Distribution Line Development.
  • $50 million for PA Sunshine (solar investments).
  • $50 million for Energy Efficiency.
  • $100 million for Technology Investment.

Basic, Special, and Early Childhood Education

  • Provides for a $400 million increase in the Basic Education Subsidy.
  • Includes a $100 million increase in the Special Education Subsidy.
  • Includes a $120 million increase in early childhood education for additional enrollment in Pre-K Counts and the Head Start Supplemental Assistance Program.
  • Includes a new Basic Education Formula that contains four goals: 1) adequacy, 2) equity, 3) predictability, and 4) accountability.
  • Includes accountability measures that address academic and fiscal performance in schools.

Charter Schools

  • Sets the regular education tuition rate for cyber charter schools at $5,950.
  • Applies the formula recommended by the Special Education Funding Commission to cyber charter schools.
  • Makes permanent in law the policy of stopping charter and cyber charter schools from being paid twice for the same employee pension costs.
  • Includes a requirement for an annual reconciliation whereby charter and cyber charter schools would refund money to their sending school districts if the charter school’s audited expenditures were less than its tuition revenue.

Higher Education and Workforce Development

  • Provides $15 million to support and modernize career and technical education.
  • Provides $5 million for Career and Technical Education Equipment grants.
  • Provides $9 million from Pennsylvania Higher Education Assistance Agency (PHEAA) proceeds to re-establish the state’s Dual Enrollment Grant Program.
  • Provides $8 million for career counselors for middle and high school students.
  • Provides a $15 million increase to community colleges.
  • Provides a $45.3 million increase to the Pennsylvania State System of Higher Education.
  • Provides an $80.9 million increase to State-Related Universities (i.e., Penn State University, Temple University, the University of Pittsburgh, and Lincoln University).
  • Calls on community colleges and the universities of the State System of Higher Education to freeze tuition during the next academic year.
  • Recommends $7.5 million from PHEAA proceeds for STEM—Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math.
  • Provides a $10 million increase to offer additional scholarships under the Ready to Succeed program.
  • Provides a $5 million increase for grants to independent colleges and universities (known as Institutional Assistance Grants).
  • Provides $8.5 million from PHEAA proceeds to expand the state’s loan forgiveness program for primary care physicians in medically underserved areas.
  • Provides a $10 million increase for Industry Partnerships.
  • Provides $8 million in funding for the Workforce and Economic Development Network of Pennsylvania (WEDnetPA).
  • Provides a $1.2 million increase for the Pennsylvania College of Technology and an $863,000 increase for the Thaddeus Stevens College of Technology.
  • Provides an increase of $466,000 for scholarships to graduates of Lincoln and Cheyney Universities who pursue graduate and professional degrees at state-related universities.
  • Provides a $475,000 increase for grants to offset tuition and other expenses for gifted students who attend Cheyney University.
  • Provides an increase of $4.6 million for Adult and Family Literacy programs.
  • Provides a $5 million increase for Vocational Rehabilitation.

Health Care

  • Expands Medicaid into a single consolidated system.
  • Expands coverage of the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) to an additional 15,881 children.

Drug and Alcohol Treatment

  • Provides a $2.5 million increase to Behavioral Health Services.
  • Provides a $5 million increase to the Department of Drug and Alcohol Programs to address heroin use and opioid addiction throughout the state.

Public Safety

  • Funds four classes of Pennsylvania State Police Troopers (or 350 new cadets).

Care for Vulnerable Citizens

  • Expands home-and community-based long-term care by providing an additional $31 million to the Department of Human Services (previously called the Department of Public Welfare) and $7.3 million to the Department of Aging to allow more individuals to obtain care in their homes.
  • Provides for the implementation of managed long-term care within three years.
  • Implements an online home care registry for workers to find jobs in the field and for consumers to find competent care.
  • Provides $45.9 million to reduce waiting lists for individuals with physical and intellectual disabilities (and expands services for these individuals).
  • Provides an additional $19.3 million for home-and community-based care for individuals with intellectual disabilities and autism (and includes $12.8 million to fully annualize the 2014-2015 program expansion).

Labor and Employment

  • Provides for an increase in Pennsylvania’s minimum wage from $7.25 to $10.10 and ties it to inflation.

Note: The information contained in this document is from public materials made available by the Pennsylvania Office of the Budget.   This document serves as a condensed summary of the provisions of Governor Wolf’s proposed budgetIt is not an official source on the Governor’s proposed 2015-2016 budget.

*     *     *    *     *

If you have questions please contact Michelle Vezzani at or the public affairs professional with whom you work.

Liquor Privatization, Déjà vu all over again?

The stories are countless, a new resident to Pennsylvania goes grocery shopping for the first time and is astounded when they can’t find either the beer or wine aisles. Or you are amazed when you go to the Food Lion in North Carolina to stock up for your beach vacation and lo and behold you can buy not only a case of beer but a bottle of wine.

Since the repeal of Prohibition way back in 1933 the Commonwealth has constructed a set of laws and regulations so arcane and unintelligible that you would need to look even further back in history to the rules of court in ancient Byzantium for guidance.

Now I am old enough to remember when I went to the “State Store” and I had to place my order to a clerk who then disappeared into the back and sometimes actually came back with something resembling what I desired.  Now of course we have “Wine and Spirits” shops where I can actually see and touch what I am ordering.  But no beer!

Change comes at a glacial pace.  Governors Thornburg, Ridge and Corbett tried with nothing to show for their efforts.

Under Governor Corbett the latest attempt was made to change the system, and then Majority Leader Mike Turzai actually defied history and passed his bill through the State House.  It died an unseemly death in the State Senate. With the defeat of Corbett it seemed as if the issue was dead, or at least dormant.

But credit, now Speaker Mike Turzai, who has pledged to get Pennsylvania out of the liquor business once and for all.  As part of any negotiation on revenue increases in this year’s budget Turzai has made it a condition that liquor privatization must be passed and signed by Governor Wolf. A new privatization bill by Turzai is waiting to be launched any day now.

How will this play out? Will the Senate finally pass Turzai’s bill? Will Governor Tom Wolf sign it? Stay tuned during the next six months.

by Nello Giorgetti

 *     *     *     *     *

If you have questions please contact Michelle Vezzani at or the public affairs professional with whom you work.